KK Fashion Exports

Crease-Resistant Finishes on Woven Cotton Fabric: DMDHEU, Citric Acid and BTCA Tests by Dhiman and Chakraborty, Lou et al. and Cai et al.

In Dhiman and Chakraborty’s tests on plain woven cotton fabric, “modified DMDHEU performed better in terms of DP rating as well as overall physical properties as compared to those obtained with citric acid.” That result covers their own recipes only. The recipes they compared also held a silicone softener and a polyethylene emulsion.

A crease-resistant finish bonds a crosslinking agent to the cellulose in cotton. The fabric is padded with the finishing bath, dried, and then cured with heat. Dhiman and Chakraborty describe the two agents they used as working by “etherification and esterification crosslinking reaction with cellulose respectively”: modified DMDHEU by etherification, citric acid by esterification.

Their DMDHEU product was BASF’s Fixapret F-ECO Plus, with a magnesium chloride catalyst. Their citric acid bath used a sodium hypophosphite (SHP) catalyst. The fabric was padded, dried and “cured under stretched conditions”. They measured total crease recovery angle (TCRA) with AATCC 66, tensile strength with ISO 13934-1, and tear strength with ASTM D1424. Retention is the finished fabric’s strength as a percentage of the unfinished fabric’s.

Tabell A. Dhiman and Chakraborty’s finishing runs on plain woven cotton fabric: the range across each set of runs. Modified DMDHEU runs were cured at 160 eller 170 °C i 3 til 5 min. Citric acid runs were cured at 180 °C i 60 til 120 s. Every run in both sets also held a silicone softener and a polyethylene emulsion. Kilde: Dhiman and Chakraborty, Tabell 12 (p. 14) and Table 14 (p. 16).
Stoff TCRA (°) Tensile strength retention (%) Tear strength retention (%) Hvithetsindeks
Warp Innslag Warp Innslag
Unfinished 155 100 100 100 100 78.80
Modified DMDHEU runs (15) 222 til 263 65.2 til 77.03 57.37 til 70.16 77.63 til 89 76.09 til 84.87 78.97 til 81.46
Citric acid runs (8) 195 til 223 64.99 til 74.92 61.56 til 70.24 72.99 til 80.9 72.78 til 82.25 75.08 til 77.17

What did a silicone softener or a polyethylene emulsion in the modified DMDHEU bath do to strength retention on Dhiman and Chakraborty’s plain woven cotton fabric?

Dhiman and Chakraborty report that the “presence of SS [silikon mykner] … resulted in better tensile strength compared to those of finished in its absence”, and that the polyethylene emulsion (PE) “played important role on retention of tear strength”. Table B shows all five recipes they used to test this.

All five recipes used the same modified DMDHEU setting. Only the softener and the emulsion changed. No recipe held both. The two recipes with softener kept more tensile strength, renning og islett, than the three without it. The two recipes with emulsion kept more tear strength, renning og islett, than the three without it. The recipe with neither additive kept the least tensile and tear strength in both directions. The authors write that the “absence of softener and polyethylene emulsion increased stiffness”. That recipe has the longest bending length in Table B, renning og islett.

The authors also note that “even presence of softener caused better TCRA”. I tabell B, both softener recipes have a higher TCRA than the other three.

Tabell B. Five modified DMDHEU recipes on Dhiman and Chakraborty’s plain woven cotton fabric, with and without a silicone softener (SS) and a polyethylene emulsion (PE). All five used modified DMDHEU at 60 gpl, MgCl2 på 20% on weight of resin, and curing at 160 °C i 4 min. Kilde: Dhiman and Chakraborty, Tabell 13 (p. 15).
Recipe SS (gpl) PE (gpl) TCRA (°) Tensile strength retention (%) Tear strength retention (%) Bending length (cm)
Warp Innslag Warp Innslag Warp Innslag
Unfinished – – 155 100 100 100 100 2.3 1.52
1 0 0 199 52.47 50.22 60.62 62.46 2.5 1.6
2 0 10 203 57.96 58.03 75.89 73.3 2.1 1.58
3 0 20 211 60.47 57.79 76.64 72.25 2.2 1.55
4 10 0 218 63.62 61.08 65.9 64.04 2.3 1.55
5 20 0 236 66.61 68.24 66.75 67.98 2.1 1.53

Related reading: Plisser som holder og plisser som faller ut.

Did the citric acid recipes yellow Dhiman and Chakraborty’s plain woven cotton fabric, and what did moistening do?

Ja, at the curing temperature the authors call too high. They write that “too high curing temperature […] developed yellowness in finished fabric due to formation of unsaturated acids”, and that “the yellowness disappeared completely on moistening (vask) of finished fabric for 30 s”.

They name the unsaturated acids as itaconic and aconitic acid, formed when citric acid loses water. In their account, moistening turns these back into citric acid. Table C gives the whiteness index of seven citric acid trial recipes before and after that wash. In every trial, the whiteness index was higher after the wash.

Tabell C. Hvithetsindeks (WI) of Dhiman and Chakraborty’s citric acid trial recipes on plain woven cotton fabric, før vask (BW) and after wash (AW). Each trial is a separate recipe. All trials held SS at 10 gpl and were cured at 180 °C i 2 min. SHP is % on weight of citric acid. Kilde: Dhiman and Chakraborty, Tabell 8 (p. 11); curing conditions from the text on pp. 10–11.
Trial Citric acid (gpl) SHP (%) PE (gpl) DP rating WI before wash WI after wash
1 60 80 10 3.5 69.31 77.82
2 60 65 5 3.4 69.63 79.20
3 60 80 5 3.5 71.04 79.12
4 80 65 10 3.5 69.13 78.75
5 80 50 5 3.5 67.66 77.31
6 40 80 10 3 71.86 79.11
7 40 65 5 2.9 73.08 78.88

For their final citric acid runs, the authors give a second route. They write that the “Whiteness index was found to be close to the unfinished cotton fabric after keeping it in open for 24 h”. In Table A, the whiteness index of every citric acid run is below the unfinished fabric’s. The paper does not say whether those values were measured before or after the 24 hours in open air.

How did curing temperature change the whiteness and tear strength of Cai et al.’s citric-acid-finished plain woven cotton fabric?

Cai et al. tilstand: “The whiteness index always decreases with the temperature rising.” They chose their best curing temperature as the point where “the wrinkle recovery angle (WRA) reaches a relatively high value”, while tear strength retention was “still” high in their words.

Their fabric was desized, scoured, bleached and mercerized plain woven cotton. The bath held citric acid with an SHP catalyst. The methods name no softener in the bath. Each sample was cured for 3 min at one of several temperatures, then “washed in tap water for 3 min to remove the unreacted CA and SHP”, and dried before testing. So their whiteness index was measured after this rinse. The text does not state the range of temperatures tested.

Most of the paper studies the reaction between citric acid and cellulose by infrared spectroscopy. The whiteness and tear findings above are a small part of it. For whiteness index tests at the bleaching stage, se innlegget vårt om peroxide bleaching and whiteness of cotton fabric.

How fast did a water drop soak into Lou et al.’s DMDHEU-, BTCA- and GA-treated cotton woven fabric, and how white was it?

Slowly. Lou et al. report “the wetting time of DMDHEU-, BTCA- and GA-treated fabrics” as much longer than that of their openSu-treated fabric, which was “similar to the reference”. Table D gives the values the authors state in their text.

openSu is the authors’ own new finishing agent, a carboxylated polyaldehyde sucrose. This changes how the other labels should be read. The authors write that the comparison baths “contained BTCA, GA or DMDHEU and the corresponding catalyst (MgCl2 or SHP) in addition to 80 g/L openSu”. The reference fabric “was finished with water”. GA is glutaraldehyde.

Wetting time was measured with AATCC 79: a drop of water is placed on the fabric and timed until it disappears. A longer time means the fabric takes up water more slowly. Forfatterne konkluderer: “the higher the anti-wrinkle performance of the finished fabrics, the poorer the hydrophilicity performance as seen with the BTCA, DMDHEU and GA finished fabrics.”

On whiteness, the BTCA- and GA-treated fabrics had a lower whiteness index than the openSu-treated fabric. The text gives no whiteness index for the DMDHEU-treated fabric. The authors link the loss of whiteness to “unsaturated and colored compounds” formed during curing.

Table D. Wetting time and whiteness index of Lou et al.’s treated cotton woven fabrics, using the authors’ etiketter. Values are those stated in the text; none are read from the bar charts. Kilde: Lou et al., text on Fig. 5 (p. 6).
Stoff (authors’ etikett) Wetting time Hvithetsindeks
Referanse, finished with water “similar to” openSu-treated Not stated in text
openSu-treated less than 3 s 72.1
DMDHEU-treated more than 42 s Not stated in text
BTCA-treated more than 42 s 61.4
GA-treated more than 42 s 65.5

Was the stiffer cotton woven fabric in Lou et al. also the one with higher crease recovery?

Ja, by the authors’ reading. They write that “the stiffness of the fabric was related to WRA, and the fabric with higher WRA had greater stiffness.” Table E sets out what they state for each fabric.

Stiffness here is bending length, measured with ISO 9073-7. A strip of fabric is pushed over an edge until it bends down to a set angle. A longer bending length means a stiffer fabric. The authors measured wrinkle recovery angle (WRA) with AATCC 66, warp plus weft.

The BTCA- and GA-treated fabrics had the longest bending lengths. The text describes the BTCA-treated fabric as having a higher WRA than the openSu-treated fabric. For the GA-treated fabric, the text gives two descriptions: in the Fig. 5 discussion, its WRA is “almost similar” to openSu; in the Fig. 6 discussion, the WRA of the BTCA and GA fabrics “was also higher”. The relation is the authors’ inference from these few fabrics. It is not a tested rule.

Table E. Bending length and wrinkle recovery angle (WRA) of Lou et al.’s treated cotton woven fabrics, as stated in the text, using the authors’ etiketter. Kilde: Lou et al., text on Fig. 5 and Fig. 6 (p. 6).
Stoff (authors’ etikett) Bending length WRA (renning + innslag)
Referanse, finished with water 1 cm shorter than openSu-treated Not stated in text
openSu-treated 5.65 cm 258°
DMDHEU-treated “similar to” openSu-treated “almost similar” to openSu-treated
BTCA-treated 5.81 cm higher than openSu-treated
GA-treated 5.76 cm “almost similar” to openSu-treated (Fig. 5 text); “also higher” (Fig. 6 text)

Kilder:

KK Fashion Exports has served buyers worldwide since 2003. Minstebestillingen vår er fra 100 stykker for trykte skjerf og 200 for kjoler og kaftaner, per stil, per farge.

Utvikle en kolleksjon for dameklær? Se hvordan vi arbeider som dameklærprodusent i India.

Se B2B-lookbooks → et glimt av våre nyeste kolleksjoner. Be om hele utvalget: flere design på forespørsel.

Grunnlaget vårt: Sadh Samaj Charitable Trust · Help and Support Foundation

WhatsApp