KK Fashion Exports

תפרים, Weave and Drape: Drape Coefficient Tests on Viscose Fabric by Yücel and Gürarda and Çeven

In Gürarda and Çeven’s tests on eight viscose fabrics, the drape coefficient showed a “very strong positive correlation with bending length, flexurall [sic] and overall flexural rigidity” (ע. 185). That is a result for their eight fabrics only, and a correlation does not prove cause.

Both papers measured drape on a Cusick drapemeter. A round specimen hangs over a smaller disc, and its shadow is traced on a paper ring. The drape coefficient is the share of the ring that the shadow covers. A higher drape coefficient means a stiffer fabric that drapes less. A lower one means a softer fall.

In Yücel’s tests on nine plain-weave viscose fabrics, what did one straight seam do to the drape coefficient?

Yücel’s Tables 2 אל 5 show that the seam raised the drape coefficient on his seven lighter fabrics, with every stitch type and at both stitch densities (טבלה A). His abstract states this as a general rule, but his own tables do not support it on every fabric.

On the two heaviest fabrics, 8 ו 9, the result split by stitch type. Both overlock seams still raised the drape coefficient. The lockstitch samples measured below the unsewn fabric at both stitch densities. The chain-stitch samples also measured below the unsewn fabric, except on fabric 8 at the higher density, where the sewn and unsewn values were effectively level.

Yücel’s explanation is that the seam allowance lies under the specimen as a second layer and holds it up against gravity, and that the sewing thread joins the two pieces and makes the seam line stiffer. It is an explanation only. The paper did not measure bending, so it does not test it.

All nine fabrics were viscose in plain weave. Each specimen got one straight seam in the warp direction, along the diameter of the circle. The fabric was sewn first and then cut into a 30 cm circle. The stitch types were lockstitch (301), two-thread chain stitch (401), three-thread overlock (504) and four-thread overlock (512). Each was sewn at two stitch densities, one stitch per centimetre apart, with 2-ply polyester thread and a size 12 מחט. Each sample was draped ten times after 24 hours at 20 °C ו- 65% relative humidity. This was one seam on a flat circle of cloth, not a garment.

טבלה A. Drape coefficient (%) of Yücel’s nine plain-weave viscose fabrics, unsewn and with one straight warp-direction seam, by stitch type and stitch density. Mean values; the paper’s CV columns are left out. Fabrics are numbered from lightest (1) to heaviest (9); the paper labels them by weight. מקור: Yücel 2012, Tab. 1 אל 5.
בד Paper’s label (g/m²) Unsewn Lockstitch תפר שרשרת Three-thread overlock Four-thread overlock
4 תפרים/ס״מ 5 תפרים/ס״מ 4 תפרים/ס״מ 5 תפרים/ס״מ 4 תפרים/ס״מ 5 תפרים/ס״מ 4 תפרים/ס״מ 5 תפרים/ס״מ
1 (הכי קל) 107 26.27 35.03 39.29 36.12 38.93 39.90 42.94 40.93 45.98
2 118 27.39 38.15 39.45 36.87 39.98 41.19 43.91 43.01 46.74
3 130 30.36 38.10 39.91 39.15 41.85 43.11 44.09 44.01 47.09
4 145 32.10 38.65 41.16 40.91 42.89 44.99 45.85 45.91 48.05
5 167 38.91 41.58 43.10 43.16 45.60 46.88 47.81 47.89 49.03
6 190 41.10 42.65 43.92 45.59 46.88 47.91 48.09 49.96 50.86
7 227 41.90 43.59 44.67 45.71 47.65 50.66 51.01 51.86 52.08
8 246 49.15 44.19 45.88 47.89 49.16 53.95 54.05 53.82 54.06
9 (heaviest) 270 51.66 46.81 48.02 49.09 50.55 54.99 55.16 55.93 56.03

Which stitch type raised the drape coefficient of Yücel’s viscose fabrics most, and which least?

Yücel reports that the four-thread overlock gave the highest drape coefficient and that the lockstitch had the smallest effect. Table A bears this out with two narrow exceptions. The four-thread overlock was highest in every fabric and density but one: on fabric 8 at the lower density, the three-thread overlock was marginally higher. The lockstitch was lowest in all but two cells: בד 1 at the higher density and fabric 2 at the lower density, where the chain stitch was lower.

The chain stitch sat below the three-thread overlock in every cell. Yücel suggests the four-thread overlock stiffens most because it puts more sewing thread into the seam line. This is his suggestion; he did not count or weigh the thread.

Stitch type was not the only thing that changed between these seams. The lockstitch and chain stitch were sewn with a 1 cm seam allowance. Both overlocks had a 7 mm seam width. Each stitch type also ran on its own machine. So Table A compares whole seams, not the stitch alone. For seam choices on light fabrics, ראו את המדריך שלנו בנושא גימורי תפרים לשמלות ארוגות קלות.

Did one more stitch per centimetre change the drape coefficient of Yücel’s viscose fabrics?

Yücel’s “Difference” column is positive for every fabric and every stitch type (טבלה B). That column is the drape coefficient at the higher stitch density minus the value at the lower density. It is not the sewn fabric minus the unsewn fabric.

For both overlocks, the gap fell from the lightest fabrics to the heaviest, with small reversals along the way. For the lockstitch and chain stitch, the gap was more uneven. On the five heaviest fabrics, these two stitches showed a bigger gap than either overlock. The largest gap in the paper was the four-thread overlock on fabric 1.

טבלה B. Yücel’s “Difference” column for every fabric and stitch type: drape coefficient at 5 stitches/cm minus drape coefficient at 4 תפרים/ס״מ, in percentage points. It is not sewn minus unsewn. Fabrics are numbered as in Table A. מקור: Yücel 2012, Tab. 2 אל 5.
בד Lockstitch תפר שרשרת Three-thread overlock Four-thread overlock
1 (הכי קל) 4.26 2.81 3.04 5.05
2 1.30 3.11 2.72 3.73
3 1.81 2.70 0.98 3.08
4 2.51 1.98 0.86 2.14
5 1.52 2.44 0.93 1.14
6 1.27 1.29 0.18 0.90
7 1.08 1.94 0.35 0.22
8 1.69 1.27 0.10 0.24
9 (heaviest) 1.21 1.46 0.17 0.10

In Gürarda and Çeven’s eight viscose fabrics, did plain or twill weave give the lower drape coefficient?

Gürarda and Çeven’s Table 3 puts both the lowest and the highest drape coefficient on plain-weave fabrics: P6 lowest and P7 highest (טבלה C). The four twills, T1 to T4, fell between them. So weave alone did not set the order in this set of fabrics.

The twills are not pure viscose. Their warp is viscose, but their weft is a viscose/polyester 80/20 blend. The plain fabrics P5 to P8 are viscose in both directions, except that P7’s warp is listed as “Floss”. The two groups therefore differ in fibre, yarn and thread density as well as weave. In the SNK test, P7 shared the highest group with three of the twills.

The paper also cites a rule from Hunter, Fan and Chau (2009): at the same mass per unit area, a twill has a lower drape coefficient than a plain weave. That rule is a citation from the literature. These eight fabrics were not built to test it, and the paper does not claim they confirm it.

Drape was measured on a Cusick drapemeter to ISO 9073-9, לאחר 24 hours at 20 ± 2 °C ו- 65 ± 2% relative humidity. The results were compared by ANOVA and the SNK test. For another weave comparison, לראות weave and tear tests on cotton and linen woven fabric.

טבלה C. Drape coefficient (%) of Gürarda and Çeven’s eight fabrics, with SNK group letters (the same letter means not significantly different). Weave and fibres as listed in their Table 1. מקור: Gürarda and Çeven 2017, Tables 1 ו 3.
Fabric code אריגה Warp fibre Weft fibre Drape coefficient (%) SNK group
T1 טוויל 3/1/1/1 ויסקוזה Viscose/polyester blend 31.76 c
T2 טוויל 3/1/1/1 ויסקוזה Viscose/polyester blend 31.13 c
T3 טוויל 2/1 ויסקוזה Viscose/polyester blend 31.52 c
T4 טוויל 2/1 ויסקוזה Viscose/polyester blend 29.97 ב
P5 מישור ויסקוזה ויסקוזה 28.72 ב
P6 מישור ויסקוזה ויסקוזה 25.56 א
P7 מישור Floss (as listed) ויסקוזה 34.25 c
P8 מישור ויסקוזה ויסקוזה 30.43 ב

How stiff in bending were Gürarda and Çeven’s viscose fabrics, warp against weft?

Gürarda and Çeven’s Table 2 shows that every fabric was stiffer along the warp than along the weft, in both bending length and flexural rigidity (Table D). P6 was the least stiff fabric on every bending measure. P7 was the stiffest on every measure.

Among the twills, whose weft is a viscose/polyester 80/20 blend, T1 was the stiffest on every measure except weft bending length. The paper states that P7 and T1 were significantly different from the other fabrics. The SNK letters in Table D show this on most bending measures, but not all: T1 shares its weft flexural rigidity group with T3 and T4, and P7 shares its weft bending length group with T4.

Bending was measured on a cantilever stiffness tester to ASTM D1388 and TS 1409. A strip of fabric slides out over an edge until it bends down to a set angle. Bending length is half of that overhang. Flexural rigidity is calculated from the bending length and the fabric’s mass per unit area. Overall flexural rigidity combines the warp and weft values.

Table D. Cantilever bending results for Gürarda and Çeven’s eight fabrics, with SNK group letters. T1 to T4 are twills with a viscose/polyester blend weft; P5 to P8 are plain weave. מקור: Gürarda and Çeven 2017, טבלה 2.
Fabric code Bending length (ס"מ) Flexural rigidity (mg·ס"מ) Overall flexural rigidity (mg·ס"מ)
לעקם ערב לעקם ערב
T1 1.38 d 1.12 e 42.36 d 22.69 d 147.81 d
T2 1.24 c 1.10 d 28.15 c 19.29 c 102.26 c
T3 1.24 c 1.09 d 30.75 c 20.91 d 115.93 c
T4 1.22 c 1.16 f 26.32 c 22.64 d 116.11 c
P5 1.12 ב 0.90 ב 23.11 ב 11.90 ב 57.12 ב
P6 0.95 א 0.85 א 9.10 א 6.47 א 19.53 א
P7 1.53 e 1.18 f 55.57 e 25.74 e 192.14 e
P8 1.25 c 0.96 c 30.70 c 13.79 ב 76.55 ב

מקורות: Yücel, Ö. (2012). “Effect of seamed viscose fabrics on drape coefficient”. Tekstil 61(1–6), 101–106. https://hrcak.srce.hr/file/204416. Gürarda, א. & Çeven, ה. K. (2017). “Influence of Women’s Dress Woven Fabric Structure on Bending and Drapability Properties”. Uludağ University Journal of the Faculty of Engineering 22(1), 179–186. DOI 10.17482/uumfd.309475. https://doi.org/10.17482/uumfd.309475. PDF: https://dergipark.org.tr/tr/download/article-file/298310.

KK Fashion Exports has served buyers worldwide since 2003. מינימום ההזמנה שלנו הוא מ- 100 חתיכות עבור צעיפים מודפסים ו 200 לשמלות וקפטנים, לכל סגנון, לכל צבע.

פיתוח קולקציית בגדי נשים? ראו איך אנחנו עובדים כ- יצרן בגדי נשים בהודו.

צפה ב-B2B lookbooks → הצצה לקולקציות האחרונות שלנו. בקש את המגוון המלא: עיצובים נוספים לפי בקשה.

היסודות שלנו: Sadh Samaj Charitable Trust · Help and Support Foundation

WhatsApp